Hi Zack,
The problem is that - like many - you want to use a new tool (Moodle) to
replicate an old one. I suggest a different approach: exploring the whole range of resources and
activities offered by the new tool (Moodle) to envisage
a new teaching strategy, make the most of the new tool and maybe, into the bargain, provide your learners with a better learning experience.
All the best,
Joseph
PS.- On this topic of new tools and old ways, may I recommend my favorite article once again?
Colleges Should Tap the Pedagogical Potential of the World-Wide Web by ALISTAIR B. FRASER