Correcting assignments

Correcting assignments

Andy Neil發表於
Number of replies: 28
Hi, we teach at a secondary school and are interested in highlighting mistakes made in work that has been submitted by pupils and then sending it back to them with suggestions for corrections.  We can't work out how to do this, apart from copying and pasting the whole assignment into the teachers comment box, highlighting errors and then sending it back to the pupil.  There must be a quicker way?  Can anyone help?  
評比平均分數: -
In reply to Andy Neil

Re: Correcting assignments

Chardelle Busch發表於
Core developers的相片
You could try the online assignment with the comment inline option:

Comment inline

If this option is selected, then the original submission will be copied into the feedback comment field during grading, making it easier to comment inline (using a different color, perhaps) or to edit the original text.


In reply to Chardelle Busch

Re: Correcting assignments

Karen Williams發表於

Hi Chardelle

I'm fairly new to Moodle and as an administrator I'm expected to know everything! I'm just investigating online marking and wanted to try your suggestion above. Unfortunately, I can't find the comment inline option anywhere! Could you humour me please and give me an idea of where to find this option.

Unfortunately, our resident Moodle expert has recently left and so far hasn't been replaced, so I'm being bombarded with questions I don't have any answers to!

Thanks in anticipation!

Karen

In reply to Karen Williams

Re: Correcting assignments

Ray Lawrence發表於
Hi Karen,

Select the on-line text assignment type and click the next button - you'll then see this option.

Ray
附件 comment.png
In reply to Andy Neil

Re: Correcting assignments

Marshal Anderson發表於
I think it depends on the type of assignment. We've been looking at sorting out the easiest way to: provide the student with detailed feedback but also create a nice list of grades and comments they can look back at. Our only solution was to downlaod the (usually) word file > open and mark in word > cut/paste a summary comment from there into the Moodle teacher's comment bit> e-mail the word file to the student.

This isn't great, but I don't see, with the current system, a better way. It would help to be able to upload the annotated word file to moodle for the student to collect - even better open the file in word and save changes direct to the server (hmmmmm, maybe that's possible locally). FWIW, this is pretty much teh way the OU do it - download, unpack, mark, upload, student collects.

Better ideas welcome 微笑

Marshal
In reply to Marshal Anderson

Re: Correcting assignments

Michael Penney發表於

FWIW, this is pretty much teh way the OU do it - download, unpack, mark, upload, student collects

This is available in the UploadReview assignment plug-in available here:

http://cdc.humboldt.edu/moodle/course/view.php?id=3&topic=3

New assignment type, upload and review, student uploads file, teacher downloads it, marks it, uploads it back again, student can view original file, marked file, comments, and grades.

Running Word on the server would be pretty problematic, as Word isn't meant to be used simulaneously by different users. It may be that plug ins to the rumored upcoming web enabled office suites from Sun/Google and MS would enable this.

In reply to Michael Penney

Re: Correcting assignments

Mohan Pillai發表於

Hi,

I am trying to install this plug-in, but it is not clear to me where to install it. Could you guide me to install this one.

I do not find the folder assignment/type to copy the uploadreview folder.

If you could tell me the exact steps to follow that would be great.

thanks and waiting for your reponse.

-Mohan

In reply to Mohan Pillai

Re: Correcting assignments

Michael Penney發表於

Look in yourmoodleinstall/mod/assignment. There should be a type folder inside assignment. If not, then what version of Moodle are you running?

This plug-in only works on Moodle 1.5 and above, it won't work on 1.4.

In reply to Michael Penney

Re: Correcting assignments

Brian Sea發表於
Michael:

I was exploring humboldt's site and stole most of your blocks 大笑  I was wondering how I would customize the course_menu block?

I'm in the midst of trying to get a university to support moodle (over blackboard) so I'm looking into ways of making things easier for the instructors.

thanks,

In reply to Michael Penney

Re: Correcting assignments - upload review

Marshal Anderson發表於
This addition is absolutly what we needed and it slotted in smoothly.  Easily edited and returned students' work - only thing we needed to be careful of was uploading annotated work /before/ writing in comment box or it got cleared.

I sort of got the impression that this also should have been able to deal with multiple files from one student for any given assignment, but it didn't seem to do that.

Not sure how all this works, but shouldn't this become part of the standard module?

Toodle pip

Marshal
In reply to Michael Penney

Re: Correcting assignments

Lynne Harrison發表於
We've installed the Upload Review plug in and it works very well for the tutor who uploads the response file and for the student concerned.  Our problem is that we want other tutors, teaching other parts of the same course, to be able to acccess the response from the marking tutor.  Although the 'other' tutors and the administrators can see the student's uploaded assignment file and the tutor comment box, neither group can see the uploaded file from the 'marking' tutor.

Really hoping that there is a way round this or I'm going to have to ask all marking tutor's to cut and paste into the comments box where presumably they will not be able to use Track Changes on the word docs submitted by the students.
In reply to Lynne Harrison

Re: Correcting assignments

Mark Pearson發表於
When I had problems with the Upload Review plugin (basically it's non-functional on Moodle systems using the Postgres database, as we are) I created a workaround which involves uploading the corrected assignment into a wiki instead. This may well solve your problem since you should be able to configure the wiki so that the individual student and all tutors have read access. A description of the problem and my workaround is here on my IT Tiddlings quikiweb site.

Mark
In reply to Michael Penney

Re: Correcting assignments

Geoffrey Rowland發表於
Michael, we are big fans of the UploadReview assignment module, and the other blocks you have developed at Humboldt. Can't wait for them to become 'Moodle mainstream'.

However, after recently upgrading to Moodle 1.5.3+ (on Fedora Core 4, using XAMPP 1.4.16: Apache 2.0.54, MySQL 4.1.14, PHP 5.0.4 or 4.4.0) we have found a slight glitch with UploadReview.

On submitting feedback to a student, a 'Changes Saved' window is presented with no [Continue] button. With Internet Explorer there is just a blank window (apart from the Changes Saved title). With Firefox there are also a couple of lines of errors e.g.
-- opener.document.getElementById("com1082").innerHTML="This is just a test ...";
opener.document.getElementById("g1082").innerHTML="0 / 0";

If you close this window, and if necessary refresh, the feedback is submitted - so things are more-or-less working, just not very elegant.

Not sure if this is related to 'missing button' problems discussed towards the end of the 'New assignment grading interface in CVS' thread.

Any ideas?


In reply to Geoffrey Rowland

Re: Correcting assignments

Paolo Oprandi發表於
I think this is an important feature of the assignment module. It works smoothly for me so far, but I am looking forward to it being in the general release.
Paolo
In reply to Geoffrey Rowland

Re: Correcting assignments

Christian Milani發表於

Hello,

i realy like this new assignment type!! but ... will it become part of the stable moodle brach?

i have your problem too, and on 1.5.3 there is a problem in the lang/en/assignment.php file (quickgrade and another string are missing)

In reply to Michael Penney

Re: Correcting assignments

andrew nokes發表於

Hi Michael,

I have been searching for a way to mark assignment (submitted in as Word documents) on the VLE, so that I can highlight the mistakes/comments, save and give back to the learner via the VLE. (Instead of downloading/printing the document, marking then emailing back)

I came across the UploadReview plug-in you mentioned, but cannot find where I can download this from.  (i think it has moved location)

Could you please advise how I can locate this plug-in, or even if it has been replaced with something new.

Many thanks

Andrew Nokes

In reply to andrew nokes

Re: Correcting assignments

Cristina Sanchez發表於
In reply to Cristina Sanchez

Re: Correcting assignments

Remmert de Vroome發表於
Tutors at my college also needed the feature that allowed them to include returned commented assignments or other files to students as part of their feedback.

This feature is present in the 'Advanced Uploading of Files' option in the standard Assignment module as an alternative to installing the UploadReview plugin. (We're using Moodle 1.8). Select this option from the list when you're initially creating the Assignment activity in your course.

As explained earlier by Elena Ivanova (see http://moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=73879), you need to bring up the Submissions table by clicking on the 'View XXX Submissions' link. Click on the 'Grade' link and the option to upload files that are then passed on to the student should be visible. Files can be attached before or after students have submitted their assignment(s).

There does seem to be a bug though, in that if grading a submission, any comments typed in the comments box will be lost as soon as the first file to be attached in the grading is uploaded. Suggest you click 'Save changes' to save comments and the grade before attaching files. Attaching any subsequent files will not delete comments that have already been saved.

Cheers,
Remmert
In reply to Marshal Anderson

Moodle's Teacher Comments boxes automatically convert Word's Comments boxes to Hotlinks :-)

Jason Ward發表於
I comment on the students' essays in Word using comments boxes and an Autotext drop-down menu of frequent feedback with hotlinks to websites where the students can get more help or complete activities (e.g.: FRAGMENT? http://webster.commnet.edu/grammar/quizzes/fragment_fixing.htm).

Once I've made the comments in Word, I Select All and Copy / Paste the whole thing (with comments boxes) into Moodle. Moodle magically converts the comments boxes into clickable target links to feedback at the end of the essay! So the student clicks whereever they see the target marker and is taken to the related feedback which appears below the essay. The whole process is automated and works like a dream. Now that I've got the system down, I've cut down my marking time considerably. Try it!

There's more details about how to do the Autotext thing on this Moodle: http://casmoodle.aus.ac.ae/course/view.php?id=146
Log in as a guest or x password x if you would like to join / start the discussions.

Krucli wrote a great article about interactive computer-assisted feedback, which is also posted on the same Moodle:
http://casmoodle.aus.ac.ae/mod/resource/view.php?id=2139

I've also written on this topic in the Proceedings for TESOL Arabia 2005. I'll let you know when it's published. I'm typing this in a hurry, so let me know if you would like me to explain anything further.

Good luck!

Jason.
評比平均分數:Useful (1)
In reply to Jason Ward

Re: Moodle's Teacher Comments boxes automatically convert Word's Comments boxes to Hotlinks :-)

Chick Lindsay發表於
Jason,
I'm having trouble logging into your moodle autotext info at http://casmoodle.aus.ac.ae/course/view.php?id=146 as you described in your 8 November 2005 post. I'd like to read what you say about the 'autotext' marking.

I am interested in an approach to online correcting of student written work. I think that Markin is an excellent tool, but I don't know of a 'seamless' way to make it work with Moodle.

Any suggestions or further developments would be appreciated.

Chick Lindsay
In reply to Andy Neil

Re: Correcting assignments

faisal saeed發表於

Hi,

Yes there is a way, how about passing every section of the paper to a teacher. For example, grammar for ?, mechanics for Professor ?, vocabulary for instructor ?.  In this way you will save more time than you ever had.

Faisal Saeed, IEP 

In reply to Andy Neil

Re: Correcting assignments

faisal saeed發表於

Hi,

Yes there is a way, how about passing every section of the paper to a teacher. For example, grammar for ?, mechanics for Professor ?, vocabulary for instructor ?.  In this way you will save more time than you ever had.

Faisal Saeed, IEP 

In reply to Andy Neil

Re: Correcting assignments

Mike Jackson發表於
My favourite way is to use the upload/review assignment type and I use MSWord 2003 and a tablet PC to mark up the students paper just as I would do it with a pen. This is seamless to me as a teacher and I can also upload the student papers as a batch to Turnitin.
In reply to Mike Jackson

Re: Correcting assignments

Josep M. Fontana發表於
Ah, yes, I just got a Tablet PC and my life has changed. These are great for reviewing assignments. With a Tablet PC, Markin and the Assignment module reviewing assignments hasn't become a pleasant task but it certainly has become a much more comfortable one smile. Markin REALLY works great with a Tablet device, I HIGHLY recommend this application.

Josep M.