3 features suggestions

3 features suggestions

by Elena Ivanova -
Number of replies: 5
Hello everyone, smile
We have got some suggestions for features in the quiz module
I have searched tracker and could not find similar ones, but may be I was searching using the wrong terms.
Please let me know what you think about those. I can then submit a tracker item, so we can vote.
Tim, what do you think about feasibility of those?

1. Showing question statistics to students per every question (gradebook can later show stats per quiz/any other individual grade item).
Reason: Some instructors believe that quizzes provide not a grading functionality, but a learning/collaborative opportunity to students. Stats help to put everything into perspective for a learner.

Stats that can be shown per each question are:
  • Average/min/max number of points earned; distribution of scores/points - valuable for Essay questions
  • Number of peers who got the question right (or wrong)
  • Most frequent wrong answers (this is what instructor can figure out from Item Analysis page) - valuable for Short Answer, Mult choice
Some of this info is already included into Overview and Item Analysis pages, so this is a matter of showing that to students.
Suggested interface: Add additional checkboxes to the Setting page of the quiz, under the “Review options” area, thus instructor can control release of such stats.

2. Bulk manual re-grading for any question type.
Reason: Improved functionality.
At this moment we can only use Manual Grading to review/regrade essay question in bulk. It would be nice to have such feature for any question type.

E.g. in case of Short Answer question, we entered quite a lot of variations for typing “N-1”. Still some students typed that with letters (n minus one), added comments into that line, etc.
Option to review on one screen and manually regrade every attempt for that question would save a lot of time.

Even T/F questions can benefit from that, since instructor would be able to bulk-enter comments to every student on one screen.

(Related to MDL-19251 which suggests ability to grade single student's entire attempt. Though I am confused about this phrase: “ability to grade all student's attempts on a single quiz question on one screen”. This is possible only for essay questions, correct? Am I missing something?)

3. Allow student to enter written comments/explanations for every answer choice they provide, and in any question type. (Right now instructors add essay questions and ask to type comments there, but it would be nice to keep everything together for ease of submission and grading/review purposes)
Reason: Students need to be able to explain to the instructor why they chose one answer over the other, and show their decision-making process, since this is what counts.
Moodle quiz interface has a lot of space for that, which is nice.

Attachment quiz.png
Average of ratings: -
In reply to Elena Ivanova

Re: 3 features suggestions

by Joseph Rézeau -
Picture of Core developers Picture of Particularly helpful Moodlers Picture of Plugin developers Picture of Testers Picture of Translators
Hi Elena, as Tim will confirm, your suggestions#2 and #3 have already been discussed at length in this Quiz forum. I don't recall suggestion #1 having been discussed, but I think it's a good idea as well.
Joseph
In reply to Joseph Rézeau

Re: 3 features suggestions

by Elena Ivanova -
Hi Joseph,
ops...blush
I do not believe we have tracker tickets then, correct? I would be happy to add them, or vote.

upd. Found this one related to my #2. I guess I need to dig into the forum more :>

In reply to Elena Ivanova

Re: 3 features suggestions

by Tim Hunt -
Picture of Core developers Picture of Documentation writers Picture of Particularly helpful Moodlers Picture of Peer reviewers Picture of Plugin developers
Yes, I just answered in the other thread about 2. It is done, in the sense that it will be done when my question engine rewrite gets into a Moodle release.

3) After that question engine rewrite is done, a comment field for every question could by done by someone implementing a new 'question interaction model plugin'. It has some similarities to certainly based marking, which was easy to implement (http://github.com/timhunt/Moodle-Question-Engine-2/tree/new_qe/question/interaction/deferredcbm.)

1) Sounds a bit like this third-party modification: http://moodle.org/mod/data/view.php?d=13&rid=2241&filter=1. Of course, you need to think very carefully before installing a major patch like that.

That sort of functionality is not currently anywhere on my or the Open University's priority list. I don't think it fits easily into the way the quiz currently works, and the quiz is complicated enough already, so I don't see functionality like this getting into standard Moodle any time soon. But I could be wrong. I can see the benefits that functionality (as an option) brings. I just think the cost of implementing it is too hight.
In reply to Tim Hunt

Re: 3 features suggestions

by Chris Collman -
Hi all,
I am interested in a teacher comment field for each question. I do not care about the students, it is all about me smile And if this field could be used as a filter, so much the better. Tim thanks for the tip on #3, I will check it out.

I have to vet questions against lesson plans, and an ever changing set of rules and regulations. My teachers can tell me what was changed but most tend to slide the finding it in the Moodle questions onto my plate.

Chris
In reply to Elena Ivanova

Re: 3 features suggestions

by Matt Bury -
Picture of Particularly helpful Moodlers Picture of Plugin developers
Hi Elena,

As a teacher and course content designer, I think suggestion #1 is excellent. It would certainly be in line with current teaching methodologies and would significantly improve Moodle's formative assessment capabilities. The basic reasons are outlined here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formative_assessment#Formative_Assessment_in_UK_education

Just my €0.02! smile