How do you stop users from editing their own profiles? I am using moodle for a school distirct and surprise, the students misuse the heck out of being able to change their profiles, mostly the uploading of avatars. I have been through the admin settings multiple times and I would have thought the option to allow or disable profile editing would be in there somewhere, but i'll be darned if I can't find it. If someone could give me a step in the right dorection I would REALLY appreciate it. Thanks.
Log in as admin, go Site Administration > Users > Authentication and just choose the user fields you want to lock.
Considering that locking down avatars restricts the freedom of everyone owing to - in our case anyway - a tiny minority, I found it preferable to temporarily replace offending avatars on the server with a read-only image of Beaker, from the Muppet show.
Considering that locking down avatars restricts the freedom of everyone owing to - in our case anyway - a tiny minority, I found it preferable to temporarily replace offending avatars on the server with a read-only image of Beaker, from the Muppet show.
Thanks so much, I really appreciate the help. That worked fine. Good call on the read only images.
Atbildot uz J B
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Homer Morro —
James, we had a similar problem, but different enough we're hoping you can help:
We have managed to shut down the privileges to edit own profile for all users (except admin). Now, we want to allow teachers to edit their profiles. We're using the path:
Admin>Users>Permissions>Define Roles>Teachers>Edit Own Profile> Allow
We don't see, however, that privilege added to the teachers' profile.
Any suggestions?
Thanks in advance,
Homer
We have managed to shut down the privileges to edit own profile for all users (except admin). Now, we want to allow teachers to edit their profiles. We're using the path:
Admin>Users>Permissions>Define Roles>Teachers>Edit Own Profile> Allow
We don't see, however, that privilege added to the teachers' profile.
Any suggestions?
Thanks in advance,
Homer
Atbildot uz Homer Morro
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja John Isner —
To prevent a user from editing his own profile, you must prevent it in the System context. Overriding editownprofile in their User context won't have any effect because Moodle explicitly tests for this permission in System context:
has_capability('moodle/user:editownprofile',$systemcontext)
This may or may not be a bug, but it is scheduled to be revisited -- see MDL-14174.
Meanwhile, here are three methods. None of them is perfect. I'll give the pros and cons of each below.
(1) edit Authenticated user, setting moodle/user:editownprofile = Not set
or
(2) create a new role CannotEditOwnProfile with moodle/user:editownprofile = Prevent and assign it to users in the System context
or
(3) edit Authenticated user, setting moodle/user:editownprofile = Not set. Then create a new role CanEditOwnProfile with moodle/user:editownprofile = Allow and selectively assign CanEditOwnProfile to users in the System context
Comments:
(1) will prevent all users from editing their own profiles except for users with moodle/site:doanything = Allow (typically, only Administrator), so it will not work for you. This is probably what you have already done.
(2) requires the Administrator to manually assign CannotEditOwnProfile to users who SHOULD NOT be able to edit their profiles.
(3) requires the Administrator to manually assign CanEditOwnProfile to users who SHOULD be able to edit their profiles.
If only teachers should be able to edit their own profiles, then assuming there are fewer teachers than students, (3) is the most efficient solution.
Don't waste your time overriding the Teacher and Student roles. These roles are not assigned in the System context (at least they shouldn't be), so they will have no effect on users' ability to edit their own profiles.
has_capability('moodle/user:editownprofile',$systemcontext)
This may or may not be a bug, but it is scheduled to be revisited -- see MDL-14174.
Meanwhile, here are three methods. None of them is perfect. I'll give the pros and cons of each below.
(1) edit Authenticated user, setting moodle/user:editownprofile = Not set
or
(2) create a new role CannotEditOwnProfile with moodle/user:editownprofile = Prevent and assign it to users in the System context
or
(3) edit Authenticated user, setting moodle/user:editownprofile = Not set. Then create a new role CanEditOwnProfile with moodle/user:editownprofile = Allow and selectively assign CanEditOwnProfile to users in the System context
Comments:
(1) will prevent all users from editing their own profiles except for users with moodle/site:doanything = Allow (typically, only Administrator), so it will not work for you. This is probably what you have already done.
(2) requires the Administrator to manually assign CannotEditOwnProfile to users who SHOULD NOT be able to edit their profiles.
(3) requires the Administrator to manually assign CanEditOwnProfile to users who SHOULD be able to edit their profiles.
If only teachers should be able to edit their own profiles, then assuming there are fewer teachers than students, (3) is the most efficient solution.
Don't waste your time overriding the Teacher and Student roles. These roles are not assigned in the System context (at least they shouldn't be), so they will have no effect on users' ability to edit their own profiles.
Atbildot uz John Isner
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Kristen Walker —
I am trying to turn on the capability for users to edit their profiles. This was previously disabled by someone who worked on the site before me, and I am not sure how he did it.
Anyway, trying to turn the capability on via the permissions for the Authenticated User role is not having any effect. I even verified in the database that the setting is getting changed in the mdl_role_capabilities table. But, when I login in as a regular user, I still don't see the "edit profile" tab when I click on my name.
Does anyone have any idea where Moodle might be getting the idea that users don't have permission to edit their profiles. I am really stumped. Any info is much appreciated.
Thanks!
Kristen
Anyway, trying to turn the capability on via the permissions for the Authenticated User role is not having any effect. I even verified in the database that the setting is getting changed in the mdl_role_capabilities table. But, when I login in as a regular user, I still don't see the "edit profile" tab when I click on my name.
Does anyone have any idea where Moodle might be getting the idea that users don't have permission to edit their profiles. I am really stumped. Any info is much appreciated.
Thanks!
Kristen
Atbildot uz Kristen Walker
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Timothy Takemoto —
Did you check the method that James Barrett mentions above?
Atbildot uz Kristen Walker
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja John Isner —
Most likely you have set Site administration -> Users -> Permissions -> User policies -> Default role for all users = Guest. Set it back to Authorized user and users will be able to edit their own profiles. Let us know if this was the problem.
Atbildot uz John Isner
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Kristen Walker —
Hi John,
You are a miracle worker! That was it! As soon as I set the Default Role for All Users to Authenticated User, the Edit Profile tab appeared.
Thank you so much!
-Kristen
PS
Can you post a picture of your car after you paint it orange? Love the license plate!
You are a miracle worker! That was it! As soon as I set the Default Role for All Users to Authenticated User, the Edit Profile tab appeared.
Thank you so much!
-Kristen
PS
Can you post a picture of your car after you paint it orange? Love the license plate!
Atbildot uz Kristen Walker
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja John Isner —
Great, I'm glad that worked.
For ease in debugging future role-related problems, install the Role debugger. You can get it from the Modules and Plugins database (click here) and you can read an article about it here. Installation is easy -- just drop the script in your Moodle root directory. You can also post to the forum or e-mail me directly if you need help using the script or interpreting the results. It really demystifies roles and permissions.
The car below belongs to Jeffery Watkins. Can you believe it?
For ease in debugging future role-related problems, install the Role debugger. You can get it from the Modules and Plugins database (click here) and you can read an article about it here. Installation is easy -- just drop the script in your Moodle root directory. You can also post to the forum or e-mail me directly if you need help using the script or interpreting the results. It really demystifies roles and permissions.
The car below belongs to Jeffery Watkins. Can you believe it?
Atbildot uz John Isner
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Jeffery Watkins —
The car is really green. The orange is a Photoshop trick. I do have the plate though.
Jeff
Jeff
How do I replace the student-selected image with a read-only image?
Atbildot uz J B
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Lynda LaRoche —
Making a field locked does not work for our Moodle (1.8.4+), LDAP server authentication. Does anyone have any other ideas on how we can make specific user fields non-editable (for example: first name, last name, ID number)?
Atbildot uz Lynda LaRoche
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja David O'Brien —
I changed Moodle source to allow only staff to upload avatars.
The change required the addition of a new permission and the alteration of profile forms.
Now, students only have the option to display the default Moodle avatar (our equivalent of the smiley) or an "official" image taken during student enrollment for their ID cards.
I have given details of the mod to a couple of other Moodlers, if anyone else is interested in seeing how this was done they can PM me their mail address...
Jeremy
The change required the addition of a new permission and the alteration of profile forms.
Now, students only have the option to display the default Moodle avatar (our equivalent of the smiley) or an "official" image taken during student enrollment for their ID cards.
I have given details of the mod to a couple of other Moodlers, if anyone else is interested in seeing how this was done they can PM me their mail address...
Jeremy
Atbildot uz Jez H
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Teresa Gibbison —
Hi there Jeremy
Could you post the details of your mod changes to this forum for us? Either in the post or as an attachment file or patch?
Many thanks
Teresa
Could you post the details of your mod changes to this forum for us? Either in the post or as an attachment file or patch?
Many thanks
Teresa
Atbildot uz Teresa Gibbison
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Jez H —
Hello Teresa,
Within a week or two I will be re-doing these changes for release 1.9.1. When I have done that I will post a zip of the altered / commented files here.
If in the mean time you would like to see the instructions / documentation I already have please PM me your mail address.... the doc contains (some very basic) info about our server which I do not want to publish here...
Regards, Jeremy
Within a week or two I will be re-doing these changes for release 1.9.1. When I have done that I will post a zip of the altered / commented files here.
If in the mean time you would like to see the instructions / documentation I already have please PM me your mail address.... the doc contains (some very basic) info about our server which I do not want to publish here...
Regards, Jeremy
Atbildot uz Jez H
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Teresa Gibbison —
Thanks Jeremy, I can wait for you to release the info here as there is no major concern for us at present, I would just like to know how to do it if it becomes an issue!! We have some lecturers who are not happy that students can alter their image but others who agree it is their choice!! 
Cheers
Teresa
Cheers
Teresa
Atbildot uz Teresa Gibbison
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Jez H —
We allowed students to select their own avatars for several years and its nice to allow this, but characters from the muppet show became too popular 
Atbildot uz Jez H
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Annick F —
Hi Jeremy,
This is exactly what we are looking for.Would you be kind enought to email the deatails on how to acheive this.Many Thanks
Annick
Atbildot uz G D
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Amy Skezas —
Hi, I am having the opposite issue. I want users to be able to edit their profiles, and they are being blocked. I have set the default user level on the systemwide permissions to Authenticated User, and "edit own user profile" is checked as allowed, yet, people can't do it. Any suggestions? Many thanks.
Amy Skezas
Atbildot uz Amy Skezas
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Jason Hammes —
Hi Amy,
Did you figure this out? I am experiencing the same issue. My students do nto see an edit profile option even though I have the edit own user profile set to allow.
Atbildot uz G D
Re: How do you stop users (students) from editing their profiles?
Nosūtīja Khalil Amar —
I went to
Admin > Users > Permissions > Define Roles > Authenticated user
and set changeownpassword to Prohibit
Scroll down and Save