Improving analytics insight emails

Improving analytics insight emails

by Jan Dageförde -
Number of replies: 2

On our site, a few analytics models have been enabled for a couple of weeks now. Since then, we have had some complaints about the emails that we are sending to our users, particularly from teachers. They are worried that it may be either spam or even a phishing attempt. Here's a screenshot of what they look like (from an email that has been forwarded to us, asking for clarification):

Note that the complaint is not about the sender - that has been covered in MDL-65085 - but about the structure and format of the email. It consists solely of links that are not really self-explanatory if you don't know what the email is about. There is no text and, apart from the sender, no hint what site this is referring to. Apart from the report in https://moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=365850#p1547041, has anyone else experienced discussions with users about these emails?

How can we improve this? I suppose that there is no administrator setting (or at least I haven't found one). So we would probably need to change the email text in core. What additional information should the email contain to make it more "believable"?

I'd suggest adding

  • the name of the site
  • a short explanation as to why a user is getting this email
  • short descriptions that explain what the buttons are.

Anything else? Comments?

Average of ratings: Useful (2)
In reply to Jan Dageförde

Re: Improving analytics insight emails

by David Monllaó -

Hi Jan,

Thanks for forwarding the feedback you got from your users. Helen raised the topic a couple of months ago while running the Learn Moodle MOOC. We improved these insights recently and the changes have already been integrated:

For a complete list of UX improvements for analytics (Moodle 3.8) please see https://tracker.moodle.org/browse/MDL-66232 (IIRC you need to be logged in to see the list of issues in the epic)

We didn't backport MDL-66536 to stables because the changes are too aggressive for stable releases. However, we could add an explanatory text to https://github.com/moodle/moodle/blob/MOODLE_37_STABLE/analytics/templates/insight_info_message_prediction.mustache. Not sure what you think about it.

Average of ratings: Useful (1)
In reply to David Monllaó

Re: Improving analytics insight emails

by Jan Dageförde -

Hi David,

Thanks for linking to the tracker issues. Indeed, MDL-66536 makes useful additions to the email text, making the message far more believable (and even more useful). Thanks for making this change.

It is too bad that we will not be able to backport this. In the meantime, I believe that adding an explanation to the email would go a long way. Is that Mustache file the template for the email?