Chris,
Thanks for seconding my idea. Quite honestly, I first move my website to a low-cost provider because of some silly rules that were being tossed around my university, and to see what one could do for under $5 a month. Well, I found out that I could do a lot, my webpages were always alive, and I didn't have to live with the school's silly rules.
It was later that I learned that I could run Moodle from my account. Blackboard was giving me problems, and I was looking for a better solution. While investigating using a Wordpress blog, I stumbled upon Moodle. Moodle solved a number of problems for me.
Yes, I wasn't sure if I really wanted to be an LMS administrator, but I was willing to give it a try.
I have always been concerned about FERPA, and am very careful about my Moodle site. It's a tough call. My guess is that my Moodle site more secure than the school's site, but just my guess. I think the issue could be on grades... that Moodle is not secure enough for maintaining grades. Well, do I keep an accurate (and capable) gradebook in Moodle, or do I use Blackboard and go back to keeping my grades in Excel?
Over the last three years, I have asked my students (end of semester survey) to comment on Moodle versus Blackboard. So far, I have had only one student say "it doesn't matter." Everyone else has favored Moodle.
So, do I do something that is better for students, or better for administration?
At this point, I hope to be able to continue running Moodle.