Request for Development: All or Nothing Matching and Drag and Drop

Request for Development: All or Nothing Matching and Drag and Drop

Scott Andre –
Vastuste arv 11

Our group is looking to obtain a version of the matching and drag and drop question types that offers all-or-nothing marking rather than partial marking. 

We are willing to finance the development in order to have this put into the community. Forgive me and please correct me if this is not the appropriate forum or approach for sharing this sort of request. My assumption is that others might be interested in being able to leverage this type of functionality as well. Jean-Michel, is something you would be open to developing?

Keskmine hinnang: -
Vastuses Scott Andre

Re: Request for Development: All or Nothing Matching and Drag and Drop

Marcus Green –
Core developers pilt Particularly helpful Moodlers pilt Plugin developers pilt Testers pilt

You probably need to clarify what you mean by drag and drop question types.  There is the drag and drop matching (as in two lists of items) and then there is the range of drag and drop question types from the OU such as ddwtos and also the image related ones.

Keskmine hinnang: -
Vastuses Scott Andre

Re: Request for Development: All or Nothing Matching and Drag and Drop

Daniel Thies –
Core developers pilt Plugin developers pilt Testers pilt

Hello Scott,

I was thinking about this for a few weeks and thought of implementing it as a set of behaviour plugins instead of modifying the question types. I have tried implementations for adaptive and deferred feedback for now. In principle they add an all or nothing option to any partial credit question type.

I would be happy if your group could look at testing it and providing feedback.

Keskmine hinnang:Useful (2)
Vastuses Daniel Thies

Re: Request for Development: All or Nothing Matching and Drag and Drop

Scott Andre –

I have a group that would be ready, willing and able to provide testing using our staging environment which is operating on v2.7. Thanks!

Keskmine hinnang: -
Vastuses Scott Andre

Re: Request for Development: All or Nothing Matching and Drag and Drop

Daniel Thies –
Core developers pilt Plugin developers pilt Testers pilt

Thank you. The plugins should work for 2.6+ and whatever experience you have in 2.7 should apply to the current quiz unless something changed substantially of which I am not aware.

The plugins can be downloaded and installed from the git repo links above. Please let me know if you have any difficulties.

Keskmine hinnang:Useful (2)
Vastuses Daniel Thies

Re: Request for Development: All or Nothing Matching and Drag and Drop

Martin Vojtela –

Great work Daniel, works like a charm!

Keskmine hinnang: -
Vastuses Daniel Thies

Re: Request for Development: All or Nothing Matching and Drag and Drop

Erika Khoury –

How can I use this behavior for certain questions on the quiz, but not for every question?  I need some of the question to be hand-scored.

Keskmine hinnang: -
Vastuses Erika Khoury

Re: Request for Development: All or Nothing Matching and Drag and Drop

Tim Hunt –
Core developers pilt Documentation writers pilt Particularly helpful Moodlers pilt Peer reviewers pilt Plugin developers pilt

What type of question?

'Essay' questions are always manually graded.

Keskmine hinnang: -
Vastuses Tim Hunt

Re: Request for Development: All or Nothing Matching and Drag and Drop

Erika Khoury –

For example:  Embedded Answers (Cloze) question type.

I am trying to have some questions not to be: Deferred Question (All or nothing) only some. But since I added that behavior to the quiz all the grading is all-or-nothing for all the questions.

Is there a way to have different behaviors on the same quiz?


Thanks for replying,


Erika


Keskmine hinnang: -
Vastuses Erika Khoury

Re: Request for Development: All or Nothing Matching and Drag and Drop

Daniel Thies –
Core developers pilt Plugin developers pilt Testers pilt

Hello Erika,

As far as I know it is only possible to apply question behaviour to a quiz as a whole so the plugin must apply to all questions. I considered this to be a feature of using the question behaviour because for some question types having some questions graded with partial credit and others not may be confusing to students.

Developing a version of cloze that is all or nothing would probably be not be that difficult, but it is not something that can be done without writing some code. It would be simpler if you could split your quiz in two.

Daniel

Keskmine hinnang: -