Hi Barfus, Gordon and everybody,
I thought your question, Barfuss, "Is it possible to make a similar comparison between "Adding the hotpot as an activity" (directly from the course frontpage) and "Adding the hotpot as a quiz" (importing it into the question bank)?" and Gordon's answer really useful. I'd like to take it further.
Like Gordon, I mainly use Hot Potatoes, these days through QuizPort, for making learning exercises and only use Quiz for testing.
However, I realise that it's partly because I'm just more familiar with Hot Potatoes and so it's quicker for me to create exercises that way. But recently Tim Hunt put up a list of Quiz Question Types and I realised that there are a lot of things that can be done in Quiz that I wasn't aware of. His list doesn't make explicit what each type actually does because that wasn't his purpose in making the list. I feel it would be really useful to have a list that does make that clear.
Stan Bogdanov has already done this and more for HP with his Hot Potatoes Taxonomy & Samples. People new to HP are often put off by the "look" of the exercises in Martin Holmes and Stewart Arneil's tutorials, for example: "How can I make it look like my website, and not web circa 2001. How can I add flashier graphics?" Jay asked recently (June 1) on the Hot Potatoes Users Group. Stan not only shows examples, he also provides tutorials on how to achieve this.
Deborah Delin is busy exploring what can be done with Xerte because it uses Flash and can integrate sound in a way Quiz and HP can't (or at least, I don't know how to do so) and also proposes different exercise types such as "hot spots" images and classifying. (See Deborah's blog and the Moodle for Language Teaching forum for more details.) I'd really love to be able to insert Xerte exercises into QuizPort but I don't know how to. Though Xerte is a html page, it can't be added to a QuizPort sequence like a "normal" html page.
Cheers,
Glenys