Is this option, or something like it, going to be in the main Moodle distribution? I was just about to write up some instructions on how Moodle can replace a standard mailing list for notifying all students when my colleague pointed out that students can silently remove themselves from it.
Even if you take the view that students should control their own email (and I am sympathetic to that) currently there is no way for students to easily switch off all but 'important' emails, so they either get bombarded with email or they get none at all. Is there some compromise postion?
There could be a checkbox at the bottom of the teacher's text entry areas in 'subscribe all' forums to override any other options and ensure that the post goes to everyone in 'emergencies'.
This combined with three stages of email activation:
* all mail
* no mail from optional forums
* no mail from any forum
Alternatively, is there an easy way to see who on your course is 'de-activated'? Maybe a warning: "3 students and 1 teacher will not receive this post via email" with a clickable link to see who they are.
(N Hansen mentioned that people are unaware of the auto-subscribe feature. I've found this to be true with my colleagues. Perhaps there could be an explanatory note on the first email from a forum after being auto-subscribed explaining why the email is being sent and where to change the option?)