The future of Moodle "learning analytics?"

The future of Moodle "learning analytics?"

by Wen Hao Chuang -
Number of replies: 9

Dear all:

I just read the 2011 Horizon Report published by NMC, and one of the buzzwords in this report is "learning analytics."

Just wondering what people here think about applying more "learning analytics" in Moodle, the potentials, limitations, and student privacy issues. Thoughts or comments?

By the way, there are two recent ELI Webinars which also talked about this, see:

Bring Data: Analytics, Outcomes, and the Role of IT Leadership

Learning Analytics: A Foundation for Informed Change in Higher Education

Best,

Wen

Average of ratings: -
In reply to Wen Hao Chuang

Re: The future of Moodle "learning analytics?"

by Tim Hunt -
Picture of Core developers Picture of Documentation writers Picture of Particularly helpful Moodlers Picture of Peer reviewers Picture of Plugin developers
In reply to Tim Hunt

Re: The future of Moodle "learning analytics?"

by Colin Fraser -
Picture of Documentation writers Picture of Testers

Prediction is always just that, prediction, no matter how deeply rooted in current trends and stats and analysis it may be, it is still just an educated guess. I suggest that the chance of error is still close to 1. In 1939, President Roosevelt asked a "Commission of the Future" to do the same, and they missed out on penecillin and television but made rocket travel common. They also go a lot of things right btw, but who really knew?

In education though, we are struggling with the technology being thrown at us, almost daily. We thought television was going to be a great education tool, but it turned to mass entertainment, little used in education. Though the capability is still there, more so now with Discovery and Nat Geo programs widely available on DVD, it is only used very specifically in Australian classrooms. With computers, we are still struggling to fit them in, but they have already been made a little redundant or will be supplanted by mobile phones and other converging technologies.

I doubt there is any prediction that can be of any real value at this point, the field is so wide open even best guesses are going to be hugely wide of the reality. The value of these kinds of reports is that we get to see what is becoming available, and perhaps it will stimulate our interest sufficiently to investigate how we can use it in the classroom. That is about it...

In reply to Tim Hunt

Re: The future of Moodle "learning analytics?"

by Wen Hao Chuang -

Hi Tim, very interesting analysis! Thanks for sharing your blog. I have bookmarked it and will come back to visit it often...

In reply to Wen Hao Chuang

Re: The future of Moodle "learning analytics?"

by Colin Fraser -
Picture of Documentation writers Picture of Testers

Hi Wen,

"Analytics" is that then new buzzword? A cross between statistics and analysis? I have run into this idea before and the basic concept is a nonsense. It promises so much but the reality is that unless you have the training and/or experience to be able to interpret what you are looking at, then the whole thing can become a rather dangerous pre-occupation. It is interesting that your link to Tony Bates' blog clearly states the risk. The Fraser Institute (no connection) has done an enormous amount of damage to education in particular because of their insistence on focussing attention on the superficialities, and not just in Canada. A quick look over their site should make any reasonable person shudder and I am at a complete loss to understand why these people have been given so much credibility.

Remember the old saw: "Lies, damned lies and statistics" - that is analytics and any good accountant can make any set of figures say what he/she wants them to say. And we "trust" these people?

In reply to Wen Hao Chuang

Re: The future of Moodle "learning analytics?"

by Martin Dougiamas -
Picture of Core developers Picture of Documentation writers Picture of Moodle HQ Picture of Particularly helpful Moodlers Picture of Plugin developers Picture of Testers

Just a quick reply, I think analytics are definitely very important and I know a lot of people are working on them (including us, soon).

Here is a specific example that might clarify the sort of thing that I think will be useful.

You're a teacher of a class with 100 students.  You have hooked up your mobile phone to your Moodle site and configured the site to send you messages.  A background analytics process runs on the Moodle site, constantly monitoring and evaluating live statistics for usage, grades and so on.

The software notices that Jimmy Student has not logged on for two weeks, and that his grades have been dropping.  As a result, you get a notification on your phone telling you that "Jimmy seems to be having some trouble at the moment, his grades are dropping and he's not been seen much recently.  In fact the same thing happened last year at about the same time.  His mobile phone number is +94834893849 if you want to give him a call."  You click the link and it dials the number.

There's a lot of other use cases but I think that sort of example is quite compelling as a way to directly assist teachers do their job every day.

In reply to Martin Dougiamas

Re: The future of Moodle "learning analytics?"

by Deb Sarlin -

Thanks for the post Martin,

Is there any information out yet on Moodle's plans for learning analytics?

Here's a link to another voice on the possibilities... http://people.kmi.open.ac.uk/sbs/2011/12/learning-analytics-ascilite2011-keynote/

While, we could certainly simply leave the process of sense-making from data and meaning-making from complex paths and visuals to others (think Google, Facebook, etc.) now that our movement through these digital domains we enter leave colorful strands that can be traced….  But, as educators it seems we do need to step into the conversation focusing on how we might sensitively use and shape this gathering or gathered information.  I think we do need to place ourselves as storytellers and picture interpreters in this new messy landscape. 

I'm excited to see what Moodlers can put in place.

D

In reply to Martin Dougiamas

Re: The future of Moodle "learning analytics?"

by Richard van Iwaarden -
Picture of Particularly helpful Moodlers

This is a great example Martin, and the call from my teachers gets louder and louder for functionality like this.

Since this was posted over 2 years ago, i would really like to know your vision on this. Will it be Moodle reporting this, or will it be another program doing this for Moodle?

We are exploring options to get more out of learning analytics. I'm just in doubt which path to take: should we find someone who can build this in Moodle for us, should we find a company that builds there own app, or should we try to hook up with something like Qlikview?

Your opinion, as always, will be greatly appreciated here smile