This doesn't sound like what the recompletion plugin is designed to do.
Recompletion is designed for courses that are required to be taken multiple times - for example a Health & Safety course which an employee is required to complete every 12 months. They complete the course the first time, and then 12 months later their progress within the course is deleted and the employee is emailed and asked to retake the same course again.
I think to do what you are asking for will require some custom development but someone else in the community might have an idea how you could achieve this behaviour.