Following our misadventures with the Rubric Advanced grading method, we are now seriously considering the development of a "Feedback Rubric". I thought it would be worth seeing if anyone else had any suggestions for it before it goes ahead or would also be interested in this (& potentially contribute to the development).
The Rubric advanced grading method is nice in the way it allows markers to easily pick feedback descriptors & is easy for students to review. However, during our online marking pilots this had serious rounding errors and it was not appropriate for grading.
Therefore, a "feedback rubric" similar to the existing rubric but which does not influence the grade & which can be combined with a Moodle Scale (which would be the sole source of the grade) would need to be developed to provide good feedback and reliable grades.
Additionally, we are thinking it would be beneficial if the "Feedback rubric" could allow multiple descriptors to be picked on each row.
Here's a mockup for the marker view: