Moodle research

Research around the Moodle book module - early days

This discussion has been locked because a year has elapsed since the last post. Please start a new discussion topic.
Picture of David Jones
Research around the Moodle book module - early days
Group Plugin developers

G'day All,

The following is an overdue and tentative announcement of a project slowly getting underway around the Moodle book module.

The project has perhaps three main aims

  1. Explore how the Moodle book module can be leveraged to create Open Educational Resources (OERs) or an "open book".
    This is the main aim of the grant funding this work.
  2. Discover what other enhancements to the book module might be useful (and implement some of them).
  3. Explore the process of making these changes and its impact on learning and teaching.

The last is quite tentative.

This post is the first of many steps to make sure that the project is open and contributes appropriately to the Moodle community.  Any advice, comments, critique or suggestions welcome. The next large step for the project will be a presentation at MoodleMoot AU'2015.

The recent Quiz research survey that Michael and Tim appear to be invovled with, appears to offer an approach that could be usefully used as part of this project.   Michael and Tim, if you had any insights or advice to share, I'm all ears.


Average of ratings: -
My mug
Re: Research around the Moodle book module - early days
Group Core developersGroup Moodle Course Creator Certificate holdersGroup Plugin developersGroup Testers

Hi, David.

It's good to see this project getting some exposure.

If you would like to construct a survey of use and potential enhancements, a good place might be on the MootAu15 website. I will create a course associated with your presentation now so you can begin work on the survey.

We can come back here and promote the survey when it is ready.

Average of ratings: -
Picture of Natalie Denmeade
Re: Research around the Moodle book module - early days

It so happens I was looking for tools to create OER content this week ... I spent some time today on the Stories4learning ebook creation tool designed by one of our Moodle community 'manxman'. The underlying pedagogy is the Read to Learn program. As I looked closer, Manxman has implemented alot of  features. It would be great to integrate some of these into the Book module.

Average of ratings: -
Just wondering . . .
Re: Research around the Moodle book module - early days
Group Particularly helpful Moodlers

Any more news David?

At present one will soon reach a brick wall for simple things to do with the book, so I'm interested in point 2.  Is there any discussion happening anywhere?

Are you just thinking of content ie 'books' or do you have anything in the way of interaction in mind?

I've been looking at Adapt:

You have a few other models for just content:



Average of ratings: -
Picture of David Jones
Re: Research around the Moodle book module - early days
Group Plugin developers
G'day Derek,

Progress update

The next big step in what I'm doing will be this presentation at Moodlemoot'AU 2015. Associated with that presentation is a Moodle course. The plan is that some initial discussions will take place in that course and then migrate to another venue.

In preparation for that presentation I'm currently retrieving and analysing any mentioned of the Book module in the English language Moodle Community forums. The aim is to identify what people have said about the Book module over the years. In particular, the type of bugs, complaints, and feature requests they've mentioned.

The plan is to try to identify categories of potential feature requests and use those to spark further suggestions and discussions around the presentation.

If necessary, I'll be adding my own ideas. However, even a cursory glance at the previous discussions suggest that most have been thought of at some stage.

I've currently got 1400 posts that mention "book module". That seems a very round number suggesting that it's not all the posts, just the limit on the forum search. Hence I need to refine this a bit more.

An obvious other source of ideas will be other tools and systems that you and Natalie have pointed to. I'll be looking at those as well.

Some possibilities and a fine line

The spark for this work is scratching my own itches. I use the Moodle book fairly heavily and would like that process to be more straight forward and have some additional functionality.

At the same time, I'm a little leery of a few fine lines to be tread. For example
  • If more functionality around interaction is added to the Book module, when does it become the Lesson module?
  • Is the goal of the Book module to be yet another authoring/publishing tool?

Another reason for looking at past community discussions around the Book module is to gain some insights into these types of questions.

The added functionality that's on my personal list are
  • Fixes to the import function.

    This is one where I've already contributed a patch to Tracker.

  • Implement a search functionality.

    It appears that something along the lines of the forum search function could be implemented easily enough. Questions remain about impact. But the need is certaintly there.

  • Produce an ePub (or other eBook) format.

    This is one that's been mentioned previously in the Moodle community forums. My initial idea here is that it would be possible to create an "ebook" out of all (or selected) books in a course.

    It's an idea with issues, but also some benefits. Especially in terms of the project funding this work.

  • Enable use of github (or similar) as a source of content/version control.

    As an option be able to save and load the content of a Book to/from github. The aim here is to open up the content. Open for others to use, but also open to be more easily created/maintained using other authoring tools.

    One of my current thoughts is to avoid putting lots of authoring functionality into the Book module, but rather enable the use of other existing tools and the integration of that content.

Some more tentative ideas include
  • Better learning analytics.

    For both student and teacher. More insights into how people are working through the books, where they are up to etc.

  • Identifying context specific information.

    This is linked to the idea of "openness" and the Reusability Paradox. In books for my course there will be very context specific information (e.g. an assignment due date) that doesn't make sense in a new context. A new context might even be as simple as the next offering of the same course (where the assignment due date will be different). A problem with reusing content in different contexts is knowing what is contextually specific and what isn't.

Average of ratings: -