Prices for Moodle Development?

Prices for Moodle Development?

por Michelle Harrell -
Número de respostas: 13

I'm researching costs and would LOVE some feedback from Moodle developers to know if I'm being given a fair estimate. I manage a grant to create online courses at an art museum. We used Moodle and were very unhappy with how text heavy it was and were hoping to revamp our platform to be more visual and incorporate social experiences.

I've best given a list of estimates for the design and development of a customized Moodle theme for $65,000 which sounds outrageously expensive to me.  Is there standard pricing that someone could share so I know the range of expenses?

I'm happy to e-mail more information off the forum with any developers could take a closer look at the wireframes and estimates to see if these deliverables are competitive.  I will probably have to do a request for services call and that developer would definitely be considered. Right now, I am hoping we can do more with less.

 Thanks!

Média das avaliações:  -
Em resposta à Michelle Harrell

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por Richard Oelmann -
Imagem de Core developers Imagem de Plugin developers Imagem de Testers

$65000 for a customized theme is outrageous if that is all you've requested!

My own pricing for a full customised theme would be more in the region of $1000-2000, with a more basic recolouring of an existing theme being even cheaper. (Please note this is given as a comparative figure and not in any way a tout for business as I am not currently in a position to take it on anyway!). Another way to look at the costing is to look at newschoollearning.com or another moodle partner and compare to their costs.


There is no need for Moodle to be text heavy - that is about the content development not Moodle itself, or even the theme. Moodle pages are as capable of having images, video, etc as any other web page, after all at the end of the day its simply a web page with content which can be generated in labels using simple HTML., as well as simple lists of resources and activities.

It sounds to me like you may need a good instructional designer rather than spending all that money on a customised theme - and for $65k you can probably get a fairly good one on a 12 month contract!

Richard

Média das avaliações: Useful (2)
Em resposta à Michelle Harrell

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por Tim Hunt -
Imagem de Core developers Imagem de Documentation writers Imagem de Particularly helpful Moodlers Imagem de Peer reviewers Imagem de Plugin developers

On occasion the OU has outsourced Moodle development work, and our experience was that there was a huge variation in quotes you would get for the same work. We would normally get three quotes for each spec, and several time there was a factor of 10 between the cheapest and the most expensive.

And, the extremely expensive quotes were rarely the best. If you want a good safe quote, go for one of the Moodle partners that specialise in doing custom development. Remote Learner and Catalyse IT are the two names I am happy to mention, because I know and like the developers there. I will let you decide whether that is undue bias, or a good sign.

Sometimes you can get a cheeper deal by finding a self-employed freelance Moodle developer (since they have lower overheads) but you have less guarantee of quality there, so you need to take more care selecting the developer.

The process of selecting companies to outsource work to was rather frustrating at times, and I had to vent in this blog post: http://tjhunt.blogspot.co.uk/2010/11/how-not-to-sell-your-open-source.html . That may, or may not, be useful.

Média das avaliações: Useful (2)
Em resposta à Michelle Harrell

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por Ashley Holman -

$65K does seem like a very high quote for a theme.

My guess from what you said is that their quote may have included redesigning your courses, and perhaps developing new visual course material, which could explain why the quote is so high.

If they are just strictly quoting for a theme (which only changes the look-and-feel of the site, but not the content), then it sounds very expensive.  Even at $2K per day, that's 32 days of work which is significantly more time than would go into a typical theme (more like 1 or 2 days for a typical theme).

Either way, you should try getting a quote from a Moodle partner, and if possible get some mockups and/or design notes so you know the scope of what they are going to deliver.

Média das avaliações: Useful (2)
Em resposta à Michelle Harrell

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por David Mudrák -
Imagem de Core developers Imagem de Documentation writers Imagem de Moodle HQ Imagem de Particularly helpful Moodlers Imagem de Peer reviewers Imagem de Plugin developers Imagem de Plugins guardians Imagem de Testers Imagem de Translators

On the other hand, we here do not know the details of what the 65k offer actually covered. Michelle mentioned "customized theme" (which is sort of terminus technicus especially in this forum). But it's also possible it included the content, graphics, site setup, hosting and other related things. I just don't want to make Michelle feel like "hey there was a guy at the Internet who would did the same for $1,000".

I fully agree with Tim - check the Moodle partners and the Moodle jobs database.

Média das avaliações: Useful (1)
Em resposta à David Mudrák

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por Richard Oelmann -
Imagem de Core developers Imagem de Plugin developers Imagem de Testers
'if that is all you've requested' was one of my first comments David, and even with Tims 10x range observation, $6.5k would be very expensive for just a custom theme development IMO, based on what the OP commented the estimate was for - 'design and development of a customized Moodle theme'. 
And yes, Moodle partners - whether NSL, RL, Catalyst or any others - are a must to get a proper comparison of costs, not just the 'guy on the internet' who has not even seen the designs and wireframes sorriso

Of even more concern, I think though (as I'm sure, given she has posted here asking the question in the first place, Michelle will have the common sense to get a range of comparative quotes), is the perception that 'We used Moodle and were very unhappy with how text heavy it was'. I really did not want to let that sit on the forums unchallenged for others to come and find in general searches on the net or in the forum and wanted to point out that this is a content design/instructional design issue and not specifically a Moodle one. Moodle has the capacity to be either a largely text based system, or a very graphical one and that is down primarily to the design of the content added to each page and less so to the platform (or even the theme) itself.
What is the content? What are the courses trying to teach? But even without that information, the institution is an art museum and that, to me anyway, shouts images and graphics, an importance on artistic/attractive design and layout and not on overly text heavy content to the extent that the site's owners become unhappy with the platform.

Média das avaliações: Useful (2)
Em resposta à Richard Oelmann

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por Derek Chirnside -

Just to say +1.

I saw the comment in your post about "text heavy" and scrolled down to see Richard's reply.  Text heavy=someone did not know about options for building with Moodle.

Plus $65K.  They saw you coming.  sorriso  or they don't know Moodle.  Or they are actually coding a whole lot of new functionality, and it's not just a theme.

If you do go for a theme, make sure it is maintainable.

-Derek

Em resposta à Richard Oelmann

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por Michelle Harrell -

I realize I need to explain my comment about being very text heavy. I would love a theme that allows images for updates rather than text. The image below on the left is the dashboard when you login to the platform. We can show "news" but it will show as a list of text. The image on the right is a very rough wireframe of the dashboard for the new theme. The new theme would allow image thumbnails to represent updates in the course. The actual pages within the course have plenty of video and images- I'm referring to the overall navigation of the course. I'd like the entire course to be more visual to represent the great images inside the course rather than a list of titles and links. Does this make sense?

NCMA existing theme

NCMA Screenshot2

Em resposta à Michelle Harrell

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por Richard Oelmann -
Imagem de Core developers Imagem de Plugin developers Imagem de Testers

Makes perfect sense Michelle and should be perfectly possible to achieve within existing themes or with a theme customisation within a much more reasonable cost bracket than the original quote you have been given.

Talk to some of the moodle partners, take a look at some of the themes in the plugins database (Elegance, Essential, Shoehorn, Aardvark to name just a few) - even if you dont want to use those and want your own developed in line with your wireframes, they'll give you some indication of what can be done with free themes.

Course descriptions and news items can already have images included directly in the course summary (its just an html editor box, like a Moodle label) as well as adding an image file on the course settings page. Your theme then just needs to display them just the way you want them. Good/appropriate use of icon fonts as found in many of the newer themes can also enhance the look and feel of the pages.

If your wireframe design requires some associated plugin development (e.g. to turn some of the main content sections into blocks), that will boost the price a bit, but not to the level you mentioned - e.g. In your wireframe 'My Courses' has been moved to a sidebar block rather than the main content area. But this should be no more than a customisation of the existing course overview block used on the MyHome page and not a brand new development. Likewise, the Recent Activity you have in the main content area is probably a reworking of the existing Recent Activity block to make it more graphical, and ensuring the theme can take that as a block into the central area (or hard coding it into the front page).

IMO while that may increase the development cost a bit, none of that justifies the price tag given.

Média das avaliações: Useful (1)
Em resposta à Michelle Harrell

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por Gareth J Barnard -
Imagem de Core developers Imagem de Particularly helpful Moodlers Imagem de Plugin developers

Hi Michelle,

Reading your description sounds to me that you need a course format rather than a theme.  The closest contributed format that I consider matches this is the Grid format (https://moodle.org/plugins/view.php?plugin=format_grid) - ok, I do maintain it, but feel free to download and try it out.  As Richard mentioned my Shoehorn theme (demo with the Grid here: https://moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=261812), it also has some functionality where a slider is employed to navigate the content, please see from 10:30 onwards on the first video of https://moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=257579.  The latest development version has some other features demoed in a video on: https://moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=262703.

Hopefully, that should give you some ideas of what is already available.

Cheers,

Gareth

Em resposta à Michelle Harrell

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por Stuart Mealor -
I'd echo what others say, which is that there are Themes, and there is development, which are quite different. Your Theme may in fact include some development time, to integrate functionality? I'm speaking as a Moodle Partner in New Zealand (with different exchange rates and economics), but I'd say there is no way, from what you have actually said here, that this should be over $10,000. So there's a quote for you to add to your list piscando You will get the most accurate quotes by choosing a small number of possible providers, and giving them a detailed document explaining what you require. Stu.
Em resposta à David Mudrák

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por Michelle Harrell -

Just to clarify, it was a customized theme without content. I have my own instructional designers- this is only for the graphic design and front end/ back end development. We already have a Moodle course that we used one of the existing themes and host the course through another server

Though I'm only beginning to read all the comments in this thread and my personal e-mails, I feel more comfortable  negogiating and questioning. I'm definitely going to check out the Moodle partners and Moodle job database. Thank you! 

Em resposta à Michelle Harrell

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por Rosario Carcò -

Only two minor notes:

a) look here for another fancy Theme/Approach/Design:

https://moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=263412

John gives you the link to his own Moodle-Server there.

b) navigation over the whole Moodle-Site can be done like John does it or using a block like sitenavigation. My own sitenavigation block displays categories and/or courses in nested folders. This was good in Moodle 1.9 but for Moodle 2.x I need time to redesign with YUI trees and an overall look-and-feel that fits better into Moodle 2. You can download and test from the Modules&Plugings Database here:

https://moodle.org/plugins/view.php?plugin=block_sitenavigation

A quick and dirty solution would be to simply exchange the folder icons with fancier ones. My code is free and everyone can change it to display as you need/want it.

Rosario

Em resposta à Michelle Harrell

Re: Prices for Moodle Development?

por Matt Bury -
Imagem de Plugin developers

Hi Michelle and welcome to Moodle.org forums! sorriso

Yes, $65,000 for designing a theme for any web software seems excessive especially when you consider that there's over 100 themes for free in the Moodle.org plugins repository: https://moodle.org/plugins/browse.php?list=category&id=3 It's also worth noting, as Richard alluded to, that it's relatively quick and easy to take an existing theme and make a few changes (a few changes in CSS can make a huge difference to the look a feel of a site).

And yes, if you're looking for an instructional designer, I think it's best to look for a specialist, ideally someone with an M.Ed. in distance education or an M.Ed. plus significant experience with working and designing online. Online learning and teaching theory and practice aren't rocket science, it's more complicated and difficult (especially for incorporating "social experiences"). And yes, with a $65,000 budget, you could hire in a post-grad to work part-time for a few months and work closely with your staff to develop something suitable and appropriate for your gallery's particular needs: I'm of the opinion that, wherever possible, it's better to develop and cultivate in-house talent, i.e. among your own staff, than to parachute in outside consultants and service providers for most elearning projects.

Like Richard, I'm not offering my services, just offering some advice from my perspective in the hope that it's useful to you... in the spirit of sharing sorriso

Média das avaliações: Useful (1)