Choice limits and time critical choices

Choice limits and time critical choices

ved Ralf Hilgenstock -
Antal besvarelser: 4
Billede af Core developers Billede af Particularly helpful Moodlers Billede af Translators

From time to time we get feedback about problems with Choice module. Specially at the beginming of a semester universities uses the choice module to organize groups or give students options to select topics for a course with limited options per choice. The choice is opened at a predefined date and time. Lots of students start to select their choice at the same moment. Often the limits are not used correct  and more than the allowed number of students can select an option.

My assumption is that the availabilty of an option is checked when the form is opened by a student but not again if s/he is saving the selected option.  Can anybody tell me if this assumption is correct?

If this is correct we can solve this problem only if a second check is made if the student has selected then option and stores data, with a message 'thanks we've stored your choice' or 'sorry in between an other student has selected the option and the limit is 'full, please select an other option.' If student is unseccssfull he should see the form again to make a new selection.


Ralf


Gennemsnitsbedømmelse: -
I svar til Ralf Hilgenstock

Re: Choice limits and time critical choices

ved Dan Marsden -
Billede af Core developers Billede af Particularly helpful Moodlers Billede af Peer reviewers Billede af Plugin developers Billede af Plugins guardians Billede af Testers Billede af Translators

Hi Ralf, 

there's a patch in MDL-23273 that tidies this up a bit but no-one has had a chance to look at it yet! - feel free to help encourage that one along! smiler

I svar til Dan Marsden

Re: Choice limits and time critical choices

ved Ralf Hilgenstock -
Billede af Core developers Billede af Particularly helpful Moodlers Billede af Translators

Hi Dan

thanks for your advice to the tracker entry. 

Can you tell something about the plans with choice module in survey2 is been published. Are there plans to integrate choice into survey2?

Ralf

I svar til Ralf Hilgenstock

Re: Choice limits and time critical choices

ved Teresa Gibbison -

We've seen this - as Dan points out two or more students saving their choice at the same time goes over the limit however...  I have also seen the limit not working when group mode is on (often by default via the course settings).

Teachers don't realise that if group mode is on the limit is relevant for each group rather than the whole class.  I wonder if there needs to be a separate option for the limit - eg. apply limit to a) each group b) entire course.

What do other's think about this group thing?

Teresa

I svar til Teresa Gibbison

Re: Choice limits and time critical choices

ved Robert Brenstein -
My first reaction is that if a teacher wants the limit to apply to the entire course not the group, they should change the group setting of that activity (I mean to make it without groups).