Thank you, David! That was it. I made the accumulative grading look like a rubric because the teacher wanted both rubric and comments with the comments being very important to her. The settings page had the grading method set back to rubric. Changed it back to accumulative grading and it works!
It's nice to know that going back into the different parts of the workshop after the evaluations are completed to fix things as I did will not cause problems with the grading, etc..