Matching questions and special characters - M2

Matching questions and special characters - M2

von Elena Ivanova -
Anzahl Antworten: 8

I have seen several cases recently when Matching questions are very sensitive to any kind of special characters. So I was wondering if this is a bug or if we have a workaround.

Answer1:   Reasonable Domain   Match1:    0<x<9
Answer2:   Reasonable Range     Match2:     0<x<250

If you type exactly like this, then you will see only the first character (0) in the drop-downs

matching

If you will type 0 < x < 9 (add spaces), then you will always get it "wrong", unless you remove < characters.

matching2

I confirmed this on several M2 instances, including demo site.

 

Other characters that I had sometimes to remove from matching questions were '  "  and ...

Mittelwert:  -
Als Antwort auf Elena Ivanova

Re: Matching questions and special characters - M2

von Joseph Rézeau -
Nutzerbild von Core developers Nutzerbild von Particularly helpful Moodlers Nutzerbild von Plugin developers Nutzerbild von Testers Nutzerbild von Translators

@Elena,

We have exactly the same problem in the Quiz Matching question type. You must add spaces around the > and < signs for a Matching question to work.

Joseph

Mittelwert:  -
Als Antwort auf Joseph Rézeau

Re: Matching questions and special characters - M2

von Elena Ivanova -

But it still does not work traurig

I do add spaces - then I attempt the question, answering it correctly. And then my answers are always "incorrect" ... (see my second screenshot).

So to make it work I should remove any kind of character that is even remotely "special":  > < " ' ...

Mittelwert:  -
Als Antwort auf Elena Ivanova

Re: Matching questions and special characters - M2

von Joseph Rézeau -
Nutzerbild von Core developers Nutzerbild von Particularly helpful Moodlers Nutzerbild von Plugin developers Nutzerbild von Testers Nutzerbild von Translators

You're right, this is definitely a bug. One workaround is to invert your left and right columns, i.e. place the "formulas" containing < or > signs in the Question field and the "normal text" in the Answer field.

Answer1: 0<x<9      Match1:    Reasonable Domain  
Answer2: 0<x<250  Match2:     Reasonable Range    

Mittelwert:  -
Als Antwort auf Joseph Rézeau

Re: Matching questions and special characters - M2

von Joseph Rézeau -
Nutzerbild von Core developers Nutzerbild von Particularly helpful Moodlers Nutzerbild von Plugin developers Nutzerbild von Testers Nutzerbild von Translators

Reported as MDL-35448. Interested people please vote for it!

@Elena, if you can hack your moodle core files, you can use the patch I provide in the tracker, it's only 2 lines to change.

Joseph

Mittelwert:  -
Als Antwort auf Joseph Rézeau

Re: Matching questions and special characters - M2

von Elena Ivanova -

Thank you!

I have more though schüchtern

1.  Quotes

 

2. Spanish characters

accents

Mittelwert:  -
Als Antwort auf Elena Ivanova

Re: Matching questions and special characters - M2

von Joseph Rézeau -
Nutzerbild von Core developers Nutzerbild von Particularly helpful Moodlers Nutzerbild von Plugin developers Nutzerbild von Testers Nutzerbild von Translators

Quotes and Spanish characters work OK for me.

If you want to provide more examples, please give the text of matching pairs as text, not as a screenshot image, so I can simply copy-paste.

Joseph

Mittelwert:  -
Als Antwort auf Joseph Rézeau

Re: Matching questions and special characters - M2

von Elena Ivanova -

I guess if I will copy/paste the ones from my example above - it would not help to replicate the issue. But just in case: 

1. First choice

1. First match

2. Second choice

2. Second match

3. Third Choice

3."Third match"

Moodle 2.3.2+ (Build: 20120914)

Mittelwert:  -