David, some comments, but I really don't have clear thinking on this.
- Not all reviews are the same. What about a "submit for peer review" option, and an 'informal option'?
- The problem will be that some people would use this as a 'request for enhancements' platform. Which may or may not be OK.
- Maybe a voting system as well . . .
- How to have a feedback mechanism to correct errors.
I'm really interested in comments like
- ease of use, clarity of interface, functionality.
- Robustness (ie someone who knows about code and such like)
- Responsiveness of coders. Will the plugin be updated for new versions?
Not all that much help I know.