Update:
I restored a course in 1.9+ today where I wanted to keep the forum "starter questions" posted by [generic instructor], who posts in all our multiply replicated courses.
During restore, I unselected all user data, then selected user data for forums, selected "none" at the bottom of the restore (where I was offered "course" or "none" for "users").
The forum starters were there when the restore was over, and [generic instructor] was a class participant, but the other users who were in the backup (but had never posted to a forum) were not carried forward into the new classroom.
Note: [generic instructor] is a global user in both our old and new server. Thus, your mileage may vary.
Backup and restore
Restoring course with user data adds new user accounts
This discussion has been locked so you can no longer reply to it.